Emotional Exposures, Or: When Art Met Science at the Gallery

Essay by Mira Shah and Christine A. Knoop

 

It is scarcely possible to conceive of art without emotion. Art can grip and excite, bore and irritate, move and sadden its recipients. Beyond the audience’s experience, however, emotions also play a role in the production of art. The artist’s personal experiences, relationships, tastes, feelings and affective responses to other artistic influences are assumed to feed into his or her own artistic output. Indeed, many artists, like Mattias Härenstam, who is represented in the present exhibition, explicitly relate their work to their own emotional experiences. Isaac Bashevis Singer said of literature that without emotion, it becomes “sterile, silly, and actually without substance.“ The same can be said about artworks in general: even though no one is affected emotionally by each and every artwork they encounter, and even though most people’s involvement in artworks is intellectual as well as affective, one can safely assume that the emotional content of art forms a large part of both its purpose and its appeal. Non-figurative art in particular seems to be drawing mostly on affect; in the absence of a clear semiotic message, it directly appeals to individual associations, tastes, and affective responses. Similarly, Härenstam’s sculptures of trees carved into distinctly human forms, spilling entrails or providing a surrealist panoply of eyes and genitals, privilege affective comprehension over aesthetic reasoning. The same is true of Jessie Kleemann’s and Iben Mondrup’s performances which draw on imagery evoked by the moving body rather than on narrative causality.

Notably though, the emotions that play a role in art contexts are, in the majority, negative ones. Feelings of loneliness, anxiety, and isolation, anger and irritation, disgust und repulsion, sadness and shock are frequently experienced in the reception of art, and, if we are to go by the self-descriptions of artists, in its creation as well. These negative emotions, however, are mingled with other, more rewarding, pleasurable emotions. Art offers us the rare possibility to experience negative feelings in a positive way, whether they are evoked by romanticism’s vast landscapes that convey saturated loneliness and charming melancholia, by the dark and disquieting atmosphere of symbolism, or by the intriguing shock value pertaining to a lot of modernist and postmodernist art. The knowledge that “this is art”, and the personal safety guaranteed by this distancing thought, allow for a pleasurable experience of feelings, atmospheres or impressions which are avoided in everyday life. Recognizing and appreciating these emotions can be a rewarding feeling in itself, and, irrespective of its (positive or negative) valence, the affective response is a stimulating exercise of one’s emotional faculties. Hence, as much as art can make us suffer, we still seek and even enjoy the experience.

Due to the prominence of negative emotions in the creation and experience of art, as well as in the thematic focus of many artworks, science, too, tends to focus on negative emotions when it strives to find out more about affective reactions to art. In experimental settings, test persons are presented with aesthetic objects that are meant to induce negative emotions. In an ideal experiment, these negative emotions should be analogous to those people experience when faced with art in a more conventional, ‘real’ setting, such as a museum or a theatre. The artefacts presented may be actual artworks or just visual material expressly created for the purpose of a study, but in any case, they are first and foremost basic implements with a clear purpose: serving as ‘stimulus’ objects in experiments. In order to be able to serve this purpose, they need to fulfil certain aesthetic criteria. Therefore, the so-called ‘stimuli’ have a double meaning. Firstly, they are scientific material, art stand-ins that can be reproduced in similar fashion over and over, so that a statistically relevant result can be achieved. Secondly, they are the results of the experimenters’ creative abilities (or lack thereof), which shape the response to an as yet uncharted extent. Since they are reproducible and meant to evoke certain reactions, the ‘stimuli’ are neither original nor artistically innovative, but they remain the outcome of a creative mind; however, their meaning is not in the message, but in the precise reaction they are meant to trigger.

This exhibition plays with the artistic side of scientific exploration: it presents stimulus material gathered to measure the effect of negative emotions alongside artworks that deal with, are created from, or might induce negative emotions in their viewers. By juxtaposing these two different approaches, this exhibition makes their complex relation more evident. The scientific material is framed thrice: as an aesthetic artefact that is really a scientific stimulus meant to be taken for an aesthetic artefact. The purpose it serves in the lab (inducing very specific emotions) is annihilated here, as the scientific design itself is exposed to the viewer. Scientific designs always shape the observation, at least to some extent: the question you ask determines the answer you get. If science itself becomes the object of aesthetic observation – if ‘fake’ art is exhibited alongside ‘real’ art –, however, the rules change. On the one hand, the scientific prerequisite of trying to control the circumstances of reception in the experiment becomes impossible to uphold; the implements are turned into ready-mades. On the other hand, the topic of this exhibition makes it evident that art, like science, can experiment with its recipients, though perhaps less systematically and with a more open outlook. Perttu Saksa’s ape images, for instance, tell a striking tale of the harshness of a human obsession with and treatment of our next of kin, the other primates, and are therefore prone to evoking empathic indignation. Yet at the same time, they play with the notion of the uncanny by realizing and simultaneously defamiliarizing human features in animals. In so doing, they breach boundaries that are conventionally part of human identity and usually safeguarded by a repertoire of affective distancing reactions. One might argue that his artworks are likely to evoke reactions similar as well as complementary to the also displayed scientific material, which shows images of furry humans and naked animals.

By exhibiting art alongside scientific ‘stimuli’, the line between artistic experience and experimenting with art is blurred, while raising the question to what extent art, like science, might be able, or indeed willing, to determine the reactions of the audience. At the same time, the exhibition itself supports the hypothesis that in art, averse affective reactions become pleasurable if experienced in the supposedly safe realm of aesthetic experience. However, this realm can be rendered less safe if the ‘real’ finds its way into the experience. This seems to be the case in this exhibition, owing to the form (performance art), implications (colonial appropriation of animal beings), material (plants and animals on medical photographs), or intent (reconstruction of a loved one’s death) of the artworks. It seems possible that blurring the boundaries between so-called aesthetic and ‘real’ experiences might shift the frame to produce yet another experimental layer – art that denies the recipients their withdrawal to the safety of aesthetic distance and therefore holds the potential for an emotional exposure of an unsettling and involuntary but deeply affecting kind.


Christine A. Knoop was born in Munich, Germany, and studied German and French Literature and Theatre Studies at the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität in Munich and the Sorbonne in Paris. After receiving her PhD in Comparative Literature from UCL, she worked as a researcher and lecturer at Freie Universität Berlin. Currently, she is a research fellow at the Max Planck Institute for Empirical Aesthetics, Frankfurt, where she is involved in a number of empirical research projects investigating aesthetic properties of literature. She is the author of „Kundera and the Ambiguity of Authorship“ (London: Maney 2011) and co-editor of „Cumaná 1799. Alexander von Humboldt’s Voyage Between Europe and the Americas“ (Bielefeld: Aisthesis 2013), and has published a number of articles on works by Milan Kundera, Jean Genet, Paul Scheerbart, Rainer Maria Rilke, and Abbé Prévost.

Mira Shah was born in Berlin, Germany, and studied Comparative Literature, Theater and Cultural Studies at the Freie Universität Berlin and Humboldt-Universität. She then joined the Cluster “Languages of Emotion” as research assistant in the project “Aesthetic Modulation of Affective Valence” and is currently writing a dissertation on “Apes and Affect. The Rhetorics of Primatology” as member of the research group “The Reseachers’ Affects” (funded by the Volkswagen-Stiftung) at the University of Bern, Switzerland. So far she has published on modernity’s anxieties and identity construction in travel writing, violence as constituent in modern interpretations of the classic Medea myths, and on the correlation of monkeys and figurations of femininity in J.W. Goethe’s novel Die Wahlverwandtschaften.

 

 

True Will

skjermbilde-2016-10-27-kl-14-29-11

Melanie Bonajo
Hannaleena Heiska
Kamilla Langeland
Josefine Lyche
Kimmo Kumela
Kasper Muttonen

Kuratert av Hilde Jørgensen

11.11-11.12 2016

UOY

Details »

Progress vs. Regress

14859805_1412022568812389_1352542464127943502_o

Melanie Bonajo
08.11.2016
CineArt

Details »

POLITICAL PROPAGANDA

500dpi

Oksana Shalygina
Siri Borgé
Petr Pavlensky
Tania Bruguera
Anton Nikolaev
Natali Cohen Vaxberg
16.12.2015
Landmark / Bergen Kunsthall

Details »

Forside 4 2015 enkel

Fett
Zoukak
Maya Zbib
Chrystele Khodr
Francesca Borri
Dona Timani
Liwaa Yazji
Etel Adnan
10.12 2015
Kunsthall Stavanger

Details »

KNIPSU & THE SYRIAN CULTURAL CARAVAN

karavaneweb

Mohamad al Roumi
Dona Timani
Amanda Abi Khalil
Mey Sefan
Tammam Azzam
Nayssam Jalal
Khaled al Jaramani
Mohanad al Jaramani
Meyar al Roumi
Walid el Masri
Walaa Dakak
Shada Safadi
Andrea Lange
Omar Nicolas
Amélie Duhamel
Emad Mustafa
Ahmad Kaddour
Akram Al Halabi
Ali Kaaf
Ammar Abd Rabbo
Assem Al Bacha
Bahram Hajou
Dino Ahmad Ali
Firas Jabakhanji
Iman Hasbani
Jaber Al Azmeh
Kjetil Selvik
Khaled Al Khani
Khaled Takreti
Khouloud Al Zghayare
Monif Ajaj
Mohamad Omran
Muzaffar Salman
Yaser Safi
Amjad Wardeh
Eyas al Mokdad
29.05 – 31.05 2015
Festplassen & Landmark/Bergen Kunsthall

Details »

05håkonholmolsen

Marte Hodne Haugen
Julie Lillelien Porter
Rasmus Andreas Hungnes
Håkon Holm-Olsen
Pål Misje
Torgrim Sund
Hilde Jørgensen
Maya Økland
14.03 2015
Kreuzberg Pavillon

Details »

1529780_743660532350164_5475029602069354884_o

Vapen och Dramatik
Mariken Halle
Ronja Svenning Berge
Clara Bodén
04.12 2014
Landmark/Bergen Kunsthall

Details »

The Wearable Art Show

wear

Kreuzberg Pavillon
Kiyoshi Yamamoto
Clemens Wilhelm
Ernst Dan Widh
Anna Törrönen
Achim Stiermann
Mariann Steiro
Tonje Høydahl Sorli
Simon Skuteli
Mari Sivertsen Norddahl
Oliver Roura
Mr. Peluche
Anne Marte Overaa
Arne Skaug Olsen
Maarja Nuurk
Olof Nimar
Paula Muhr
Eva Ljosvoll
Malin Lennström-Örtwall
Rasmus Hungnes featuring Ellen Ringstad
Azusa Kuno
Kathrin Köster
Nina Hannah Kornatz
Kveta Kazmukova
Sarah Hillebrecht
Kari Anne Helleberg
Bahri Johna Hansen
Jonathan Jung / Michel Wagenschütz
Hilde Frantzen
Benedikt Dichgans
Eleanor Clare
Wera Buck
Thomas Behling
23.08.2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Die Schwelle

schwelle

Ytter + KNIPSU;
Anngjerd Rustand
Anne Marthe Dyvi
Hilde Jørgensen
Julie Lillelien Porter
Maya Økland
28.06 – 29.06 2014
Galerie Toolbox, Berlin

Details »

Producing novel forms, alienating familiar ones: Affinities between experimental aesthetics and art production

Talk by Winfried Menninghaus

22.05 2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

The Pleasure of Negative Emotions

pleasure

Mattias Härenstam
Jessie Kleemann
Iben Mondrup
Paula Muhr
Perttu Saksa
21.05 – 15.06 2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Emotional Exposures, Or: When Art Met Science at the Gallery

Essay by Mira Shah and Christine A. Knoop

 

Details »

Anonymous Nationalist

petrpress

Petr Pavlensky
25.04 – 11.05 2014
Museum of Contemporary Art Krakow, Poland

Details »

Birth

ANELANKNIPSUweb

Ane Lan
28.03 – 27.04 2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Ave Maria

StillKNIPS1

Marte Gunnufsen
14.02 – 09.03 2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Prøverommet

proverom

27.01.2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Final-ILove-Smallweb

Mathijs van Geest
Bjørn Mortensen
Jake Davidson
Christopher Holloran
Nina Barnett
Robyn Nesbitt
Ming-Hwa Yeh
Apichaya Wanthiang
23.01 – 26.01 2014
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Into the Woods

jussiweb

Edwina Goldstone
Jussi Goman
Maija Helasvuo
Antti Oikarinen
Pilvi Ojala
Anneli Sipiläinen
Anssi Taulu
Veijo Ulmanen
15.11 – 08.12 2013
Komediebakken 9

Details »

KUNSTEN Å ÅPNE DØRER

doorw

Nora C Nerdrum
Hilde Herming
Dag Solhjell
Karin Hindsbo
Sigrun Åsebø
Annette Kierulf
Knut Jøsok
16.11.2013
Stiftelsen 3,14, Bergen

Details »

plakaten

Wiam Alaridi
Susanne Christensen
Benedicte Clementsen & Jennifer Johansson
Föreningen JA!
Frans Jacobi
Kwestan Jamal
Mor & Jerry
Olga Jitlina
Taisiya Krougovykh
Anna Kubista Löfman, Sigrid Fivelstad, Madeleine Hofsøy & Tova Fransson
Charlotte Myrbråten
Petr Pavlensky
Hilde Sofie Pettersen
Anna Prikhodko
Ekaterina Sharova
Leo Shumba, Sara Kollstrøm & Numi Thorvarsson
Ksenia Sorokina
Sound of Sotra
Annika Ström
Tanja Thorjussen
Synnøve G Wetten
09.09.2013
Fensalen/BIKS, Kong Oscarsgate 15, Bergen

Details »

gf_illegal

Gallery FIST
03.09 2013
Landmark/Bergen Kunsthall, Bergen

Details »

MBOS 660x480_220 dpi

Chto Delat?
Keti Chukhrov
Francis Hunger
31.08 – 27.10 2013
Komediebakken 9

Details »

100 år med stemmerett – så hvorfor holder kunstnerne kjeft?

anelan

Ane Lan
Grethe Melby
Samir M´kadmi
Wencke Mühleisen
Kjetil Røed
Vibeke Tandberg
15.06 2013
Litteraturhuset, Bergen

Details »

powerplakat2

Joanna Rytel
Arne Skaug Olsen
Gitte Sætre
Erik Bromö
Benedicte Leinan Clementsen
Gabriel Edvinsson
Sigrid Fivelstad
Tova Fransson
Gabriella Forzelius
Lina Grenaker
Sara Kollstrøm Heilevang
Madeleine Hofsøy
Frida McIntosh
Jennifer Johansson
Maria Jonsson
Henrik Koppen
Anne Larsen
Anna Kubista Löfman
Thea Meinert
Ina Rebecka Porselius
Leo Shumba
Numi Thorvarsson
Tord Torp
22.05 – 23.06 2013
Komediebakken 9

Details »

Terskelen

ytter2

Ytter/KNIPSU
10.05 – 02.06 2013
BOA, Oslo

Details »

KNIPSU Presenterer:

rattbild

Kunstnergruppen FRAKSJON
11.05 – 15.05 2013
Komediebakken 9

Details »

advantages

Guerrilla Girls
10.04 2013
Landmark/Bergen Kunsthall

Details »

POWER TO CHANGE! Strategies in Feminist and Human Rights Activism

gulabi

Helga Nyman
Joanna Rytel
Arne Skaug Olsen
Afrah Nasser
Steven Dixon
09.04 2013
Bergen Offentlige Bibliotek

Details »

Deelstaat=

deelstaat

Jonas Ib Jensen
Hilde Jørgensen
Marte Gunnufsen
Johannes Langkamp
Martijn Moedars
Jasmin Moeller
Maya Økland
18.03 – 31.03 2013
Extrapool, Nijmegen

Details »

Tales from the womb

TF Skolekorps(1)

Textfukkers
08.03 – 24.03 2013
Komediebakken 9

Details »